Several years ago, soon after I started writing about my life, I was asked by a reader to address an issue he thought might be of interest: How police wives are portrayed in the media. An excellent question and one I vowed to address soon. But then I realized I needed to do a lot more research. I rented movies, read books and watched tv shows about police - soaking it all in and thinking about how the wives were portrayed in each of these mediums. And that's if they were even portrayed at all. I also polled members of other police spouse forums, asking other spouses' opinions and finding out that, once again, we're all pretty much on the same page here.
It's a sad fact that while police are a popular topic for movies, books and television show, the women behind the badge rarely rate any appearances at all. And just like there are pervasive stereotypes of police in the media, there are also stereotypes of police wives. If the wives even merit attention at all. Our impact, our importance, our existence is rarely acknowledged in the world of entertainment. And with the rare exception, unflattering stereotypes seem to pervade those instances when we do show up. The following questions were posted on a popular police wives forum (www.policewivesonline.com). Here are our thoughts:
How do you feel police wives are portrayed in the movies, on television and in books?
No surprise here - most officers’ spouses feel that their positions are portrayed for the most part in several negative ways. "It seems like the wives are always bitchy and complain about having to do all the work around the house because he's never home," said one wife from Texas. "Honestly, I would divorce most of the "wives" on TV shows or movies if I was the man in their lives."
"All that comes to mind is negative views of police wives. Most of the TV shows, and movies portray us as being very crabby about all the hours, and not being home with the kids. Also I've seen a lot of shows where the LEO(law enforcement officer) wife always get's cheated on, and just looks like a total dumb a**. She's staying at home with the kids and running the household, well he's off doing his job, working many hours, kickin' ass and banging co-workers and other people on the side."
"(Many) portray us as either absolutely perfect in everyway, with no complaints ever or else we are the complete opposite and are terrible awful bitches that do nothing but whine all the time and close our eyes to the harsh reality of the convenience factor that a Cop has to cheat."
I think we (police wives) all agree that we'd like to see shows/movies/books that give law enforcement wives the credit they deserve. We are the "hidden" partners, the strength behind the badge. We often are the ones who keep the family together, and have to do it alone while our spouses are working long and non-traditional hours.
Is there a stereotype you often see? Is it accurate and/or fair?
Stereotypes are just as common for the police wife as they are for the police officer. Common ones we see are either the damsel in distress, the hapless wife sitting at home complaining and driving her husband to infidelity or the defenseless victim of domestic abuse. Oh yes, and don't forget the stripper ones, too.
"The damsel in distress. The "bad guy" is taking their child to get back at the husband or some other thing like that, and they stand there screaming, "No, please help me!" Whatever! I would at least put up a fight. But, that's many movies in general rather than just those showing police movies. Personally, I like the "damsels in distress" who at least look like they tried to fight off the attacker."
"It really bothers me when they portray (police wives) as a few things..
1. The "whore" the one that sleeps around while hubby is at work, full on tacky make up, trashy dressing etc.
2. OVERLY homely with 20 kids
3. DUMB uneducated like didn't get thru middle school!
4. Subservient, doing everything he says and beats her and she takes it.
5. The one that really irks me, that we all come from white trash families with no education and nothing in life and barely make it to live, and of course are just sooooo stupid uneducated!
6. OR we were all Badge Bunnies that broke up his marriage to get him!"
What are some of your favorite books/movies/tv shows that you feel portray positive images of police wives?
Nevertheless, there are a few shows that have had positive characters portraying police wives - and we have noticed and do appreciate it. In fact, it'd be great to see some more.
I immediately mentally reviewed common popular movies and tv shows from when I was growing up that centered around officers. There was the Lethal Weapons, Die Hard, Beverly Hills Cop, NYPD Blue, Walker Texas Ranger, Hill Street Blues, Miami Vice, C.H.I.Ps, etc. Many of these really didn't have characters portraying police wives, or if they did they were almost invisible. But here are a few that were decently positive.
Lethal Weapon 3 or 4 - the ones with Rene Russo. She was in law enforcement also and really kicked a** alongside Mel Gibson. They were married. She still was judo-kicking criminals when she was pregnant. They were portrayed as happily married, which was nice, and full partners in their relationship. Her image was not a common, realistic one of police wives, I know, but she at least was fun to watch and not someone I would hate to portray me. And come to think of it, Danny Glover's wife in that movie was also a good character. She was funny, supportive, but didn't take crap from him, a good mother, involved, caring, loving.
NYPD Blue: Sipowitz's first wife, Sharon Lawrence. She was a lawyer. Smart, beautiful, honest, caring, supportive, a working mother in a profession that allowed her to understand and be around her husband through the rough times. She's the one of the few police wives I've admired when watching tv or movie roles.
In Die Hard, Bruce Willis's wife was pretty realistic, I think, as much as that movie would allow it anyway. She was intelligent and supportive, but had also obviously had enough of the hard life and dealing with a husband never there. Of course, after he rescued her and a whole building of people and then her and a bunch of airplanes running out of fuel how could she resist going back to him? ha!
Again, this is entertainment we're talking about, and I understand a need for drama and theatrics to keep audiences entertained. But having a foundation of someone strong and intelligent rather than weak or just idiotic is much more palatable to me. Other wives chimed in with instances they've found of police wives portrayed positively:
"Faye Kellerman has a series of books. The main character is a police officer, Peter Decker. Early in the series, he meets his future wife when she is the victim of a crime. The series takes place over a number of years -- he gets promoted, they have a kid, etc -- and it seems to portray pretty close to home.
- she is supportive but finds she needs to have her own life and interests,
- she's responsible for raising the kids and managing the home because you never know what his schedule will be,
- there is one book where a lady accuses him of having an affair with her to get him in trouble at work and of course EVERYONE is sure that he did (because all cops cheat) until his wife shows up and supports him.
- they have their share of issues ... female partner, missed plans, trouble with the kids, etc.
What are some of the worst?
Here are examples of media characters police wives give a universal thumbs down to:
The quiet, meek, wife: Seven - Gwyneth Paltrow was Brad Pitt's cop character's wife. She was meek, quiet, hardly talked, looked angelic but not a big character. And her head ended up in a box.
The depressed neglected wife: Heat - Awesome movie, one of our favorites. Pacino's wife was portrayed as neglected, depressed and heading for divorce. She smoked pot to escape the pain and cheated on him (got caught on purpose) to get him to notice. Not such a good image, in my opinion.
The nonexistant wife: Training Day - Denzel is show with his girlfriend all the time, but he was married and they didn't even show the wife!
The whore: "I remember a quote from a TV show...either The Shield or Third Watch, I think....but a police officer on the show said "Cops marry hookers, nurses or other cops." It still irks me. A lot.
*reprinted from an earlier post in 2005
Written by Renee (LAPDWife), Police Wives Online Staff Member
©2005 LAPDWife.com & PoliceWivesOnline.com
This article may not be copied and/or redistrubuted without permission from both parties
Recent Comments